Summary Judgment & Defended Claims

The fast route where a debt is not genuinely disputed — and the expensive road when it is.

The summary procedure exists on a sensible premise: most debts are not genuinely disputed, and it would be absurd to require a full trial to establish what everybody knows. The financial risk in debt recovery sits almost entirely in the moment that premise fails.

Default, and the Summary Application

Judgment in default arises where the defendant simply does not respond within the time allowed. It is how most undefended debt judgments are obtained, and for a creditor it is the cheapest and quickest outcome available. For a debtor it is the most avoidable bad outcome in this entire area — judgment can be entered on a debt that was statute-barred, or overstated, or genuinely disputed, purely because nobody replied. Default judgments can sometimes be set aside on application, but that needs explanation, promptness and usually an arguable defence, and it is far harder and more expensive than responding in time would have been. Where the defendant does appear, the creditor applies for summary judgment. The court is not trying the case: it asks whether a genuine issue for trial has been raised, or whether the defence is so lacking in substance that judgment should enter now. The bar for a defendant is not high in absolute terms but it is real — bare denials, unsupported assertions and complaints about the commercial relationship that do not answer whether the sum is owed will generally not clear it.

Telling a Real Defence From a Delaying One — and What Happens Next

Usually not defences: general dissatisfaction never raised at the time; complaints about the wider relationship that do not answer this sum; an assertion the invoice is wrong without saying how; requests for documents already supplied. Usually genuine: a specific and evidenced performance or quality complaint, especially one raised contemporaneously; a set-off or counterclaim; payment made or credit due; limitation; the wrong party sued; a real dispute about the terms agreed. The distinguishing features are almost always specificity and timing. If a genuine issue is raised, the matter is remitted to plenary hearing — and at that point it stops being a debt claim and becomes ordinary litigation, with pleadings, possible discovery, evidence and trial. Time runs to many months; cost rises substantially and stops being proportionate to a modest debt. That transition is the single biggest financial risk in debt recovery. Which produces the advice creditors least expect and most need: once a claim is defended, do the arithmetic again. A discount accepted early frequently yields more actual money than a full judgment obtained expensively much later against someone who cannot pay it — and where the trading relationship still has value, mediation may be the better forum entirely.

Facing a Defence, or Expecting One?

The useful work is deciding in advance what you will do if the claim is defended - because that decision made under pressure, months in, is the one that costs creditors most.

Call 01 5827148

Related Reading

Summary Judgment - FAQs

Judgment obtained because the defendant did not respond - did not enter an appearance, or did not deliver a defence, within the time allowed. It is the most common way undefended debt judgments are obtained, and from a creditor’s perspective it is the cheapest and quickest outcome available. From a debtor’s perspective it is the most avoidable bad outcome in the whole area: judgment can be entered on a debt that was statute-barred, or overstated, or genuinely disputed, simply because nobody responded. Default judgments can sometimes be set aside on application, but that requires explanation, promptness and usually an arguable defence, and it is far harder and more expensive than responding in time would have been.

General information, not legal advice. This website contains general information about Irish law on debt recovery and enforcement. It is not legal advice and does not create a solicitor—client relationship. Every debt turns on its own facts — the documents, the dates, the parties and the debtor’s circumstances — and advice on yours requires a consultation. Statutory thresholds and figures referred to on this site are subject to change and should be confirmed before any step is taken.

A law firm, not a debt collection agency. Mary Molloy Solicitors provides legal advice and representation. It does not operate as a debt collection agency and does not conduct collection campaigns. Fees are agreed in writing with the client at the outset and are never calculated as a percentage or proportion of any sum recovered. In contentious business, a solicitor may not calculate fees or other charges as a percentage or proportion of any award or settlement.

No outcome is promised. Nothing on this site states or implies that any debt will be recovered, that any asset will be found, that any enforcement step will succeed, or that any claim will succeed. Recovery depends substantially on the debtor’s means, which are frequently unknown at the outset.

How payment may be demanded is regulated. Section 11 of the Consumer Credit Act 1995 makes it an offence to make a demand for payment by means calculated to cause alarm, distress or humiliation, or falsely to represent that legal proceedings have been or will be issued. Nothing on this site should be read as encouraging any such conduct. Mortgage arrears on a principal private residence are dealt with under a separate regulatory framework and are outside the scope of this site.

If you are the person being pursued. Free, confidential and independent money advice is available in Ireland from MABS, the Money Advice and Budgeting Service, and through the Abhaile scheme for people in mortgage arrears. You do not have to engage a solicitor to get help, and taking advice early generally improves the options available. This firm advises debtors in matters separate from those in which it acts for a creditor, and never both sides of the same debt — conflicts are checked before any substantive discussion.

Tax. Nothing on this website is tax advice. Questions about VAT on recovered sums, bad debt relief or the treatment of write-offs belong with your accountant or tax adviser and with Revenue’s own guidance.